Captain Vikram Batra, Major Saravanan, Captain Manoj Pandey ,Sqn. Ldr Ajay Ahuja, Captain Kieshing Nongrum, Lt. Saurabh Kalia, Lt. Col. Vishwanathan, Sepoy Lal Singh, Sepoy Rakesh Kumar, Sepoy Rakesh Kumar, Sepoy Raswinder Singh, Sepoy Bir Singh……..
Do these names ring a bell? I am sure not.
These names don’t mean anything to this Facebook, MTV, Orkut Crazy generation.
Ask them to name the reckless, useless winner of a reckless, useless show in MTV Roadies and you will get a prompt answer.
Well these were among the thousands brave hearts who fended off evil Pakistani army goons who had infiltrated our side of LOC in the guise of mujahideen. Ten years after India fought the most televised battle in the history of warfare in the subcontinent, Indians seemed to have moved on.
At 11.30 past night I messaged some friends ‘Happy Vijay Divas’ and ‘Kargil Forgotten’.
Some of these friends were happily and heavily drunk at a reataurant called ‘It’s Greek to Me’ and the text perhaps seemed all too Latin to them.
A Google Search cleared the haze next morning in .17 secs.
Well these very dear friends of mine actually reflects the times we are living in,that tells me that an ungrateful nation had forgotten to salute a famous victory against Pakistan.
A victory in achieving which 562 soldiers had bravely, selflessly, unquestioningly laid down their lives for their country and countrymen, i.e. us, in the cold heights of Kargil.The present generation takes lot of pride in calling themselves as ‘Liberal’ and broad minded. But even for a "liberal" nation with an equally ‘liberal’ generation which has scarcely any militaristic sentiments, it seemed too obvious an event to miss, especially given the rap the nation had received for their disgraceful send off to Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw in June.But the Sunday papers provided little proof that old habits die hard. It again reminded me that we as a nation are hardly proud of our history, culture and legacy.
The largest selling newspaper in the world ‘The Times of India’ didn’t think that Vijay Divas demanded any special mention. After all there are other important strategic issues to be covered such as Gay rights etc.
But I must say that Electronic Media proved me wrong. Almost all the prominent news channels covered it extensively. A lot of them stressed upon the history involved, reasons behind the war and aftermath.
Highly appreciated.
Ten years have passed by. But have we learnt our lessons. I regret that the answer is no.
I am not going into why Kargil happened and what could have been done 10years ago
As there is no point in crying over spilt milk. But every war teaches a lesson to the countries involved. The lessons can be categorized in some broad categories :
Political,Social,Militarily,Intelligence and Strategic.
I again regret that we have hardly learnt any lesson.
Political lessons are to be taken by the most worthless citizens in our country, the politicians. I was mad with anger over how they are scrambling to make a political issue out of this too. Congress govt not showing much enthusiasm in celebrating Vijay Divas
as according to some of them the victory came under NDA.
Those who cover the defence beat say the Kargil victory is now viewed as "an NDA/BJP victory" with which the UPA/Congress wants to have no part. "The Congress has its 1971, the BJP has its 1999," says one award-winning reporter.(That the Congress which does not want to remember 1999 could not even remember the hero of the 1971 victory(to Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw )properly tells its own story.But if true, how pathetic as a people can we be getting, that we view the triumph of the nation, the sacrifice of our soldiers, not through a wide, collective prism, but through a narrow, constricted aperture of the government of the day?Certainly, critics, skeptics and cynics in the military, media and polity have plenty of questions over how the Kargil victory was achieved: The intelligence and strategic failures, the antiquated techniques in capturing Tiger Hill (the site of most of the casualties), etc.Plus, there is the coffin scam over which the Congress walked out of the House each time then defense minister George Fernandes got up to speak.Much as those questions may be important and need to be answered, how do they take the gloss away from a great victory? And how do they make a meaningful observance meaningless?What kind of signal is such peevishness sending to the jawan in the field, and to potential recruits? What kind of impact does it have on their morale and motivation to be reminded that they are not fighting for the nation at large but for the coalition in power?Is this something over which our parties should try to score silly points?Is this how we show how much we value the armed forces?This is not to suggest that the President and prime minister and defense minister and Congress president must drop everything and break out into a bhangra every July 26 for the benefit of the television cameras. But what do they lose by gracefully acknowledging Kargil's place in our contemporary history?
This was for political class.
There are some lessons to be learned after every war which are very Militarist in nature.
Just a day before I read a report which reports that ‘CAG’ has termed the Gorshkov defense deal as totally useless. Almost all the defense deals happening are shady.
Army is equipped with sub standard weapons. Are we ready for another Kargil?
There are still so many families who have not got their due from governments.The government and the system continues to treat them shabbily. My heart goes out for them.
And now the baiton passes to us. Are we as a citizen even aware of our Army and the great role it plays in safeguarding our interests. Aren’t we so engrossed with our own busy lives and selfish dreams that we don’t even know that there is a Vijay Divas today and it needs to be celebrated.
I wish the Media plays a more proactive role in guiding the citizens towards this. e.g instead of beaming useless Reality TV programmes as ‘Rakhi Ka Swanyvar’ why not
beam a programme on War Heroes.Take some creative liberty to make it sellable. Add some fiction to the real life stories and present it to audience. Well it’s just a small idea.
I am actually quite anguished and emotional today as I write this and I might sound over the top in what I have written but am not apologetic for the same. And as I am writing this I have just watched news on TV which says that Defense Minister and Prime Minister have stayed away from the celebrations. There must be reasons for this.
And I remember a famous Urdu couplet written for freedom fighters.
शहीदो क़ी य़ाद मे लगेंगे हर बरस मेले
वतन पे मिटने वालों का बाकी यही ऩिशान होगा
Times have changed and the poor martyrs won’t know that there won’t be any ‘Mela’
for their remembrance now. The nation has forgotten them.
I will close this post with a request to have a glance at the below mentioned links.
They carry some info of my favorite heroes from Kargil War,
Captain Vikram Batra and Captain Manoj Pandey.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vikram_Batra
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manoj_Pandey
http://captainmanojpandey.tripod.com/
Also try to watch a movie called ‘1971’.One of the rare hindi movies made on POWs
(Prisoner of Wars).
And with a request to observe a silence for a minute in memory of these brave men.
That’s the least we could do.
Jai Hind.
Love,
Saket.
Jai Hind! Saket!
ReplyDeleteI agree and can relate to your frustration and anger but....I feel we Indians miss no opportunity to critise our government. Just because Jai Divas was not celebrated the way it should have been doesnt mean that our govt is sleeping or does not appreciate the sacrifices of Jawans!
My Dear Friend....the fact of life is....that life has to move on...and so the people.
You are talking about Kargil which is 10 yr old whereas we indians have fogotten the drastic incident of TAL Hotel bombing which happened few months back. Ajmal has become a hero.Period.
Again i will say we indians blame and criticise out govt. at our convenience.....just the way you have just written this article....Because there is freedom of speech in India but I would like to look at the positive side.
Before kargil happened, during those days we indians would critise the BJP govt but eventually at the time of kargil, it was the same BJP govt who did it....and we indians we only watching the TV relays eating best of foods in our houses.
My Dear Friend.....its is easy to critise...but i feel if one has the balls then WHY NOT JOIN POLITICS and make a difference to the development of our country. Why become software engineers, doctors, etc and work for foreign land to earn in dollars. And once in a while...in fre time write an article abusing the govt.
I Feel for my Jawans...I HAve not forgotten the sacrifices of our Jawans...and I am sure none of the indians have forgotten them. When you wrote this article .....may be i was watching "Rakhi ka Swayamwar" but that doesn mean that I have disrespected my Jawans in any way.
Your article has provoked me to say....that you are just assuming and putting eveyone in one box which is NOT FAIR!
This is something similar to what we indians do when our cricket team looses a game against Pakistan. We abuse them...throw rocks on their houses...critics do the writing and so on....
On the other hand when India wins the game...we make them our heroes....do pujas for the players in temples and they become the heroes....
Very conveniently we love or hate our players....but do not realise that they do lot of hard work and have the balls to face failure or success and confidently face the world.
In the end...I would like to say.....I LOVE MY JAWANS.....and I also appreciate to what our govt is doing for the dvelopment of the country.
The One who feels that they are good for nothing.....should join politics and prove a point rather complaining.
Take Care
Shivani
rightly said Saket...I was also really astonished at the politicization of such an event. I remember someone saying "we choose our own leaders".....may be WE ALL are to b blamed for this..
ReplyDeleteJai Hind Saket !!!
ReplyDeleteI do subscribe to your views and totally consent that we might have forgotten our heroes. But on the other hand we can not criticize our government solely on the basis of some media facts or reporter arguments.
The very first statement that your friends were busy boozing off at a distant pub unaware of the "Vijay Diwas" reflects the agony of this new generation. Is it not our patriotic duty to remember the dates of national importance? Is is that every year a news channel will have to tell us that tomorrow is our Republic Day, Independence Day or Gandhi Jayanti? We fondly keep track of the exact schedule of our cricket team for the next five years.......but not this !!
The whole debate of Vijay Diwas being a BJP vs Congress day is nothing but a media gimmick. The line that you quoted : "The Congress has its 1971, the BJP has its 1999," ..... is again said by a media person. Can you quote me any political party making such a statement ? I guess there will not be any. No true Indian can say that he/she is not interested in celebrating this Day.
I do agree that we had some blots during the Kargil War. Many strategic failures by the top officers which resulted in lots of casualties. And lastly, the infamous Coffin Scam which was the icing on the cake.
But have we ever noticed the scale of our defense budgets and the daily induction of crucial armory. Please google and you will see that the number of new Sukhois, warcrafts, tanks, Brahmos, ICBMs, Nuclear submarines etc... and all the advance weaponry added to the Indian armed forces during the last several years, is really enormous. Is this not a responsible role on the part of our government? I admit that there are lots of questions raised on the Gorshkov defense deal, but eventually the addition of an Aircraft carrier to our fleet will club us with the selected few countries in this world.
And lastly do we have to celebrate "Vijay Diwas" just for the sake of celebrating it. And then forget it all the very next day. Are we not happy that every day of our life is a "Vijay Diwas". That we are sleeping peacefully at nights. That we have the future with a booming economy. That we are happily coming to office and enjoying our work. That we are spending quality luxury time at malls, multiplexes and restaurants. All this because our army, government and law and order are working correctly in tandem.
I am sure that from a republican point of view, you will never want our nation to be ruled by an army instead of a stable government at the center. We have had an excellent example in the form of our neighbor Pakistan, which was ruled by General Musharraf. A total democratic failure which has become the breeding ground of terrorists since then.
One of the biggest example which we all can set is to join the army or politics ourselves. Or even join civil services. In my opinion this is one of the biggest service we can do for our nation.
Jai Hind !!!!
--SANCHIT
@Saket:
ReplyDeleteNice article and welcome to the CRIBFEST.
For the uninitiated CRIBFEST in a perpetual event held all over India. The agenda can include any of the following:
1. Why aren’t good people joining politics
2. Why do we suck at all sports except cricket and aren’t pretty good at that too
3. Some random TV show
@Shivani seems to be a veteran since she can talk about all three n the same sentence :P
Anyways my opinion:
1. We don't need the govt. to sponsor celebration of events. We are getting by on pretty much everything, if you feel Vijay Diwas needs to be celebrated go ahead and like-minded people will join in. Let the sheeple be sheep, most of them don't vote and are pretty much irrelevant in most scheme of things.
2. It was sheer providence that we had a bunch of capable and motivated army folks otherwise the govt. & army brass & the populace of this country had pretty much done everything to script territorial loss ( omission of loss of life is intentional as nobody gives a shit until and unless it’s their own or a loved one). We might not be that lucky the next time.
3. And after reading your article and comments it reaffirms by belief that the entire nation (well most of it) is waiting for someone else to volunteer and do the housekeeping. Why doesn’t someone fix this mess? Well why don’t you do it?
WHY SHOULD SOMEONE/ANYONE GET INTO POLITICS/ARMY/HOSPITALS/SCHOOLS etc. AND DEDICATE HIS/HER LIFE TO MAKE THINGS BETTER FOR THE REST OF US WHEN WE ARE PRETTY MUCH THE MOST UNDESERZVING AND ON TOP OF THAT UNGARETEFUL LOT EVER TO HAVE DESCENDED ON THIS PLANET ?
I can’t think of any good enough reasons?
Lemme know if you have some incentive for people to be good again.